01 September 2003
Parks in Mexico projecting benefits well beyond their boundaries

Better forest management brings economic and biodiversity benefits to Yucatan

NohBec, Mexico—Not far from Cancun, down the white sandy beaches that line the blue waters along Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula, lies one of North America’s most significant nature preserves, the Sian Ka’an Biosphere Reserve—a World Heritage Site—that is home to more than 100 mammal species, 346 bird species, and more than 900 species of plants. Protected and well managed, the Reserve has so far been successful in conserving the Peninsula’s unique and varied biodiversity.

But the popularity of Cancun and the Yucatan coast has added extra pressure on the unprotected forests outside the Reserve’s boundaries. There are fears that unregulated development of the area will turn Sian Ka’an—which in Mayan means “Where the Sky is Born”—into a non-viable biological island.

Yet while conservationists hope to build a biodiversity corridor from Sian Ka’an to the Calakmul Biosphere Reserve in the middle of the Yucatan Peninsula, which would ensure that large animals such as the jaguar would have enough room to roam, there is growing recognition that the local indigenous people have to materially benefit from conservation efforts.

Parks and poverty cannot coexist

There are presently more than 44,000 protected areas around the world, or about 10 percent of the world’s land surface. As a reservoir of the world’s biodiversity, these areas provide water, protect soils, filter the air and hold the promise of improving foods and medicines. Yet there has been criticism of these parks within the development community by those who believe that the preservation of wilderness areas comes at the expense of the people who live nearby.

The World Parks Congress 2003, to be held in Durban, South Africa from 8-17 September, is considered by many to represent a turning point in the debate, and a convergence of thinking of conservationists and development officials.

According to Mark Malloch Brown, Administrator of UNDP, one of the major sponsors of the Congress, there is now an acknowledgement that parks can’t exist in a vacuum. “Parks and poverty cannot coexist. While parks deliver enormous benefits for the global community, in protecting biodiversity and ecosystem services, and in mitigating the effects of climate change, they also have to provide direct benefits for the people who live nearby,” Mr. Malloch Brown adds.

Parks and the people

For the members of the Mayan community of NohBec, just 20 kilometres west of the Sian Ka’an, the forest has traditionally provided a living from the hardwoods, palm leaves and chicle—the traditional base of chewing gum. Their management of the land is based on a system of communal land tenure, the result of the ejido system that was established in Mexico in the 1930s. There are 216 families that belong to the NohBec ejido cooperative and they own 24,000 hectares of land.

The problem is that the forest, while conserved, has not produced big dividends for the community—until now. According to Saul Blanco, a forester, the community received meagre payment from private logging concessions for the tons of mahogany that were felled from its forest. “We had very little awareness of what wood was worth at that time,” says Mr. Blanco.

According to Francisco Montalvo, secretary of NohBec’s commuity council, a mix of poor administration and restrictions due to the ejido’s unique legal status was pushing the operation toward a financial crisis just a few years ago.

“The council members are people with a lot of experience in the forest, who want to preserve the forest, but who don’t know much about administration,” he said.

A crisis was averted with assistance from an international collaboration administered by UNDP known as COMPACT, or the Community Management of Protected Area Conservation. COMPACT is a joint effort between the United Nations Foundation and the Global Environment Facility’s Small Grants Programme that has helped local communities protect the biodiversity in and around World Heritage Sites in six countries on three continents.

COMPACT’s support for NohBec began in 2001 and has resulted in a number of fundamental changes to how the community does business. According to Julio Moure, COMPACT coordinator for Sian Ka’an, a series of training sessions have been held to help the ejido’s various departments coordinate their work better and improve management of their forest resources.

The changes have brought results. Last year, enough profit was earned to give each ejido member a dividend payment of 22,100 Pesos (US $2,200). And Mr. Blanco says that as profits rise, there are plans to invest more in equipment and infrastructure improvements in order to lower waste, and further increase profits.

Building a biodiversity corridor

Mr. Moure explains that there are many ejidos in the region with between 25,000 and 40,000 hectares of forest each, and that could be managed better. “According to LANDSAT images, approximately 70 percent of Sian Ka’an’s buffer zone is covered with forest that is in good, or very good shape,” says Mr. Moure. “I believe that within another five years, we could have about 500,000 hectares of forest under community sustainable management.”

—Freelance journalist David Dudenhoefer has been covering environmental issues in Latin America for more than a decade and has previously contributed to CHOICES.

Promoting protected areas
• Parks and protected areas deliver critical ecosystem services on which long-term human survival depends, and are a key indicator for the Millennium Development Goals.
• Parks and poverty cannot coexist. While ensuring a sustainable future, we cannot leave surrounding communities in poverty.
• Parks are for life, for development, for the future, for all people.
• Park managers, local communities, indigenous peoples, and other stakeholders must work together to resolve conflicts and maximize the benefits for all.
• Good governance—how decisions are made and management effected— is critical at all levels—national, local, community and the park’s themselves.

Parks Serve Nature and People
• There are more than 44,000 protected areas in the world and they cover almost 10 percent of the world’s land surface.
• Less than one percent of the world’s seas are protected.
• Only one-tenth of the estimated $30-$45 billion annually needed for proper protection of protected areas is actually allocated.
• Almost one-third of all known animal species live in so-called hotspots that together cover 1.4 percent of the world’s surface, but only about 37 percent of these are currently protected.
• About 80 percent of the population in developing countries rely on traditional medicines, mainly derived from plants for their primary health care; protected areas are the major and sometimes only reservoir for many of these plants.
• In the Democratic Republic of the Congo, people receive 75 percent of their animal protein from wild sources; in Malawi, Nepal and Tanzania people rely on firewood and dung for 90 percent of their energy needs.
• Protected areas can make money: In Costa Rica, annual tourism revenues of around $330 million more than cover protected area outlays of $12 million a year.

Mexico at a Glance
Population:
100.5 million
Area: 1,972,550 sq km
Human Development Ranking: 55 of 173 countries
Adult literacy rate: 91.4%
Population living on less than US$2 per day: 24.3%
Annual population growth rate: 1.2%
Life expectancy at birth: 73.1 years
GDP per capita: $8,430
Source: Human Development Report 2003